// ARCHITECTURE_COMPARE
MakeYourMCP vs Lunar.dev
Comparing dedicated, security-first MCP gateways with API consumption egress proxies.
Lunar.dev is an established egress API gateway designed to monitor and rate-limit external API calls. While they have introduced Model Context Protocol (MCP) integrations, their core focus differs from MakeYourMCP's zero-trust agent governance model.
Comparison Summary
| Feature | MakeYourMCP | Lunar.dev |
|---|---|---|
| Core Focus | Agent security, fine-grained RBAC, and credential isolation. | Egress API rate-limiting, cost management, and caching. |
| Granular Database Gating | Yes (Filter rows, block tables, redact outputs). | Limited (Focuses on raw API endpoints, not database schemas). |
| Visual Policy Canvas | Visual drag-and-drop policy editor. | YAML-based API routing configurations. |
| Redaction & PII Masking | Automatic data redaction based on agent role. | Requires custom interceptors. |
Architectural Focus Points
1. Security/RBAC vs. Performance/Egress
MakeYourMCP is designed from the ground up to address the security risks of autonomous AI agents. The gateway evaluates prompt injections, restricts database write permissions, and isolates database credentials from the LLM prompt context.
Lunar.dev (MCPX) is designed to manage API performance and API provider limits. It is excellent for preventing developers from exceeding Slack or Salesforce rate limits and for caching API calls. However, it lacks visual RBAC rules and granular database-schema access controls.
See how we compare to others